Tuesday, 14 October 2008

In the line of fire?



















The outbreak of communal violence in Orissa could not have come at a worse time. After a spate of terrorist attacks across the length and breadth of the country; from Agartala to Ahmedabad and from Bangalore to New Delhi, it had seemed for a while that North and South Block would wilt under public pressure to act tough on terror. However, the events in Orissa relieved that pressure and gave the Congress and the liberal media an excuse to wiggle out of a tough corner. It sometimes feels as though in democratic India, it is only terrorists who can create pressure as and when they want, with the general public being only a seasonal player.

It seemed for a while that the force had turned against the Congress and its allies. The holy cow of political correctness had been tipped; as even left liberal heroes like Rajdeep Sardesai and Barkha Dutt goaded the Congress led government for its utter inaction. The press hailed the martyrdom of Mohan Chand Sharma, the police officer who died in the Jamia Nagar encounter. Amar Singh (no less!) promised the brave inspector's family a reward of Rs. 10 lakh and the media painted those who pulled out conspiracy theories to thwart the police action in a less than glowing light. The Vice Chancellor of Jamia-Millia Islamia was quizzed over his motives behind providing legal aid to those of his students accused of heinous crimes against the state. For the left leaning English language media that holds the middle class in thrall, it was a first. It was a far cry from June 2004, when the media gasped in horror over Modi's police shooting down an "innocent" 19 year old Ishrat Jehan Sheikh, who apparently lost her way while she was going for a job interview from her home in Mumbai and wandered as far as Ahmedabad to find herself in a car with three armed men. It was a far cry even from March 2007, when the secular press shed tears of blood over the death of Sohrabuddin, the man who happened to be on a wanted list in a mere four large states. Never have so many tears been shed on the death of an innocent child in terrorist attack.

Fortunately, the freaks in the Bajrang Dal were there and eager to help. They have started a despicable campaign of violence against tribal Christians. In doing so they have handed the Congress a perfect excuse to divert the national discourse from the issue of terrorism.

Some of the violence in the Kandhmahal District is perfectly ethnic and has nothing to do with religion. But the work that the VHP and Bajrang Dal have done to consolidate the tribal Hindus has ruffled feathers in the Roman Catholic camp. In the swathes of tribal territory in the heart of India, there are many potentates trying to prey on the simple minded poor people who inhabit these regions. The third main force, apart from the Church and the Saffron brigade, is the band of Naxal rebels, who claim responsibility for the killing of VHP preacher Lakshmanananda Saraswati, the event that started the violence. In the bitter struggle for the hearts and minds of the poorest of the poor, the well funded Church has a huge advantage, an edge that the VHP seeks to meet by going berserk with violence and intimidation. Both are equally condemnable.

Now that the Catholic Church is no longer the malevolent bully it once was, its vast campaign of mental abuse goes almost unnoticed. At a time when the people of India are yearning for progress like never before; the Church is injecting superstition and bigotry into the veins of the most downtrodden of India's people. This week itself, the Church announced that it had ascertained that some Sister Alfonsa of Kerala had performed two "miracles", and this long dead person was rewarded with the status of a "saint". Now, I believe we should all be progressive and bury the records of Catholic bigotry as long as those atrocities and ideologies remain a thing of the past. But promising to help the sick and the dying, or to feed the poor and starving in return for swearing allegiance to a vast potentate of no legal international status such as the Catholic Church is most despicable. We can and we should all forgive Pope Benedict XVI (Joseph Ratzinger) for having been a member of the Hitler Youth; but when the Pope says that "condoms are more dangerous than HIV", the Church should be recognized as a force up to no good at all.

At the same time, one should not mince any words about the manner in which the Bajrang Dal brings shame to India. The most dangerous development of all is the fact that the Dal perceives that it can have a free run in any BJP ruled state. Since the reins of power in New Delhi may soon be assumed by the BJP, reining in the fanatical fringe is no small concern. The aggression of the Dal also makes life difficult for BJP allies, as the beleaguered Navin Patnaik has found out in no small measure. However, it cannot be stressed enough that the Bajrang Dal is still a bit player when it comes to the total amount of unconstitutional activity taking place in the country. Hindu fanaticism is fed almost completely by anger over Muslim appeasement and Christian guerilla warfare at the social level. For instance, the Andhra Pradesh government recently decided to award a subsidy to Christians seeking to make a pilgrimage to Jerusalem. Though the drain on the exchequer resulting from this measure will be small indeed, it is these little day to day favours to minorities that rankle in the collective Hindu mind.

While the debate over who killed the VHP preacher rages in political and police circles, some of the rhetoric indicates a worrying trend. Most of the Congress and the UPA want us to believe to that the preacher was killed by Naxals and as such the violence of the Bajrang Dal is "unjustified". First, even if Lakshmanananda had been hacked to death by Christian priests, there would have been no excuse to ransack Christian homes or burn down churches. More importantly, death at hands of Naxals is NOT a "natural" death. The murdered VHP preacher deserves to have the Naxal rebels brought to justice. The fact that the Congress and the UPA never once mentioned the menace that the Naxal scum have become speaks volumes about their commitment to public security in this country.

In fact, the Congress party should have come to its senses and gotten busy with creating an anti-terror agency that could deal with Naxals, Islamic terrorists and secessionists in the Northeast. The prospect of the creation of such an agency seems to grow dimmer by the day. Some weeks ago, after an innocent 9 year old boy was killed in New Delhi, minister Kapil Sibal assured us that the government was working overtime to come up with a solid strategy to tackle terror. As of Oct 18, 2008, nothing has been done in this direction. Instead the paltry gains made initially, such as in the Jamia Nagar encounter or in the arrest of terror masterminds, are being whittled away in endless political squabbles. Instead of acting tough on terror, the Congress party decided to call a meeting of the National Integration Council. Perhaps they should remember that the time for peace is not during the war, but after it.

Sunday, 28 September 2008

Thinking ahead : A host of new allies for India

Fresh from his success at the Nuclear Suppliers Group, the Prime Minister has decided that it is time for India to spread its wings and head for the skies. This signals the arrival of a much awaited, very opportune moment. The NSG waiver, if nothing else, was a pointer to India's destiny; it is up to Midnight's Children to pursue the dream to its glorious end. In this respect the Oracle makes a round up of the new allies India could attract in its march towards becoming a world power.

The first aim is to fix coordinates. This means having to separate allies from enemies. And once the allies have been identified, the goal should be to achieve a tactical partnership, establish the power equation in the relationship and steadfastly claim an equal if not an upper hand. As for the enemies, it is always possible to trade and/or parley with them in a mutually beneficial manner within clearly defined paramters. As senior diplomat Rajiv Sikri wrote, "India claims to have some kind of strategic relationship with all the major global players viz. Russia, France, UK, Germany, EU, Brazil and China, Japan, even Iran and Saudi Arabia!". Such a foreign policy approach marks out India as both an unreliable partner and a lightweight. With achievement comes confidence. With achievement and confidence comes power... and more achievement. For India, the cycle as been started. It is up to the diplomats to keep the wheel turning.

1. The United States: The US tilt towards India is perhaps the most important geopolitical coup since the Cold War. Owing to some strange choices made by both India and the United States, the world's two largest democracies had been somewhat estranged for sixty years. Not any more.

The United States is a powerful partner to have. Having powerful friends can be a challenge. For one, India understands that there is a long way to go before the United States accepts India as an equal partner in the relationship. Now that India has been securely drawn into the US Bloc, one should expect that American diplomats will push for more influence in India's foreign policy and perhaps even internal affairs. The US does this to all friendly nations: the UK, Canada, Germany, Australia and comes down even more heavily on allies such as Vietnam, Romania, Hungary, Poland and Georgia. Given America's continued leadership in the world since the 1950's, it is easy to understand the temptation, even the habit.

This is where diplomacy comes in. India is not the typical US ally; neither is India a small nation torn apart by the Cold War, nor an European country that was helped back to its feet by America after World War II. India is too proud to accept a relationship that is not based on mutual respect. In this respect, the lurking suspicion against America, in most middle class ranks and in political circles of both the Congress and the BJP serves us well. If India cannot eek out an honourable arrangement with America, no one will.

For this, it is important for India to stress the fact that our relationship with Russia is very important to us. Americans need to be reminded, in countless ways that a credible counterbalance to China is almost an existential necessity for them. At this time, when Russia seems to be grunting at the Western World, an indifferent India would make the East look very grim indeed for the United States.

At the same time, India probably realizes that a strategic Indo-US partnership is China's worst nightmare. Even as China presses its own people to the brink in the scramble for "world domination", an Indo-US combine, with most of the Western World taking the side of democracy, is probably too much for them.

The wonderful thing is that India has hardly put a foot wrong in its relationship with the United States so far. It's military ties with the United States have been widely advertised and it has had the right effect in Beijing. As China begins to realize that making cheap toys, toothpaste, matches, soaps and slippers for "lazy" Americans has actually made them very dependent on the US, it has adopted a wait and watch policy towards the emerging Indo-US relationship. It has made desperate attempts to reinstate the India-Pakistan hyphenation, tried some characteristically sinister ploys at NSG, but most of these efforts have come a cropper.

2) The US allies: The main dividend in pursuing a friendly relationship with the United States is the "access" to US allies. America's allies are also among our most natural allies and being in America's good books raises our profile among them. Although much of the world appreciates the rise of China and India, many nations such as Germany, England, Canada, Australia and Japan have waited to pick up the cue from America.

This is all the more reason to make sure that India is able to define its relationship with the United States in honourable terms. Since many of the nations mentioned above, though economically and sometimes even militarily potent on their own; have, by and large, taken America's primacy for granted. As such, if India manages to pursue a "new kind of" relationship with the United States, it generates genuine respect for India as a world power.

This is especially crucial, since many of these nations could be key allies. England and Germany are both key industrialized economies; from which India can learn and gain a lot. Trade and cultural ties with England being what they are, along with a shared concern over terrorism, the economic opportunities in this sphere are virtually limitless. As India looks for foreign partners to increase its share in international trade, India looks towards the European Union and North America for havens of liberal democracy very similar to our own.

The US allies can also offer India major military advantages. Indian presence in Japan, the Korean peninsula, Taiwan and Vietnam will enable India to virtually place a stranglehold on the Chinese coast. This would be a fitting reply to the ring of Chinese bases around India, in Bangladesh, Burma, Indonesia and Pakistan; a sure way to snap the infamous "string of pearls". India has already flourished in the new Afghanistan and built a military base in Tajikistan, overlooking the bridge from Pakistan to China. Shinzo Abe once said that the Indo-Japanese relationship is the most important bilateral relationship in the world. In many ways, he was right.

3. France : France has seized the opportunity to start trade nuclear material with India. When President Sarkozy arrived in India earlier this year, the diplomats had started working on the modalities for Indo-French cooperation in the nuclear sector. France, apart from being a very important member of the European Union, also has a significant military industry and most importantly; France is a NATO member state that is never shy of standing up to what it perceives as US hegemony. One might recall the funny incident when US Congressmen, miffed at France's rabid criticism of the war in Iraq, even suggested that the cafeteria on the Capitol rename French fries as "Freedom fries".

It therefore follows that a military and economic alliance with the French could serve as a nucleus for a grouping of democratic forces, which though fundamentally friendly to the US, would stand for ensuring that America does not drive the free world by its whims.

Although India has always enjoyed good relationships with England and Germany, the relations with the European Parliament have been rather strained. This is mostly due to the "holier than thou" approach of EU member states towards freedom of religion and human rights in India. Unfortunately, most EU member states are highly developed, sparsely populated nations that can never fully appreciate the sheer will it takes to drive an 1100 million-man machine like India.
A disconnect has arisen within the EU itself, where we have states such as France, England and Germany on the one hand who have big stakes in the world economy and countries like Auistria or Holland on the other which are all too smug about their civil rights rhetoric. Austria and Holland have given up all aspirations and just want to be left in peace. And if they continue to bring in more Muslims, they will die a slow painful death. This disconnect was on display at the NSG meet, where the bigger nations threw their weight behind India but the diminuitive players on the world stage agonized over technicalities of non proliferation. By opening up to France, in addition to England and Germany, India can send a message to smaller EU states that they must give up their prudish attitude and cooperate.

4. Israel : Although India did not even have relations with Israel before 1992, the growth of India-Israel relations has been truly remarkable. The relationship has rapidly spread to industry and the military.

At a time when terrorists in India are so energized, it is extremely important for Indian intelligence agencies to train with the famed Mossad, which virtually enjoys cult status. Israel has been looking to become India's No.1 supplier of weapons for some time now. Although it is quite demeaning that India should still have to shop around for its weapons, we have to wait until our very own DRDO has reaped its deadly harvest. Fortunately, with the DRDO testing missile after missile, that day no loonger seems so far away.

Of course, nothing can be achieved unless India formulates a clear Middle East policy. Continued sympathy for Palestine will never buy India any favour with the terrorists. We might as well join the other side and try to win this.

India's relationship with Israel also enjoys the generous blessing of the United States and acts as a thorn in the side of the Islamic world. There is some perverse pleasure in watching the terrorists shake their fist at the emerging India-Israel-US axis. Hail civilization. Hail democracy.

5. And finally, Africa: This might sound somewhat out of place, but it isn't. The poorest continent may not be a major military or geopolitical ally, but it certainly is brimming with mineral resources. Given India's non imperialist image in the world, the time is certainly right to get the resource rich African nations on our side. In this quest, India has a "psychological advantage" over the other predominantly white nations. The challenge is to pull this off before the Chinese do. The Chinese have already rallied with the genocidal regime in Sudan. Although one wishes that India might never have to do something so despicable as that, there is an urgency to act with a certain measure of guile. Given the number of despotic regimes in Africa, the Chinese are certain to find fraternal bonds with many African nations, just as they did with the dictators in South Asia. India can ill afford to ignore this.


Our nation has a bright future. The battle in the mind has been won. But the success story has not been scripted yet.





Friday, 26 September 2008

Those who cannot help themselves.... India to stay helpless before terror?



























Of course, India is no stranger to terror. But terrorism used to have a pattern. Once a year, the terrorists would come out of their foxholes, strike a major city and disappear. Following on this, common people would breathe fire for two weeks and then return to the bread and butter issues of daily life. The media would devote the other fifty weeks of the year to explaining why the Muslims of India are the most gentle people in the whole world; the defenceless victims of Hindu fundamentalism. The secular polity would examine each action of the communal/Hindu brigade, seeking for the smallest breach of peace, the slightest evidence of lawbreaking from the RSS/VHP/Bajrang Dal in order that all the terrorism in the world could be labelled as a "reaction" to Hindu oppression. The lack of fact was often more than made up by creating a cauldron in which news; real, fake and imaginary, was blended with paranoia by their accomplices in a very willing English language media. As the secular crowd kept India in check, Jihadi elements infiltrated the Muslim populace at will, busily working on an autonomous machine that could roll out terror attacks like cars from an assembly line. Thanks to the efforts of the Left liberals and the Secular parties; the assembly line is in place now. The Indian Mujahiddeen gave a big high-five to liberals as its new terror machine was set in operation.

Now that the cat is among the pigeons, the Government is scurrying to hide its face. On the day the terrorists scored off their second success in Delhi in the space of two weeks, the Central Government cleared 7 new proposals to fight terrorism. It's too late now. "Do not wait to dig a well until your house is on fire"; so goes the Hindi proverb, loosely translated. And, worse still, is the fact that some of the Government's new measures are merely window dressing.

The English language media has been struggling to help the "secular forces" get back on their feet. The search for diversions has been intense and the Bajrang Dal has obliged dutifully. The UPA Government was more than delighted to issue a bold warning to BJP ruled states of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Karnataka to protect the life liberty and property of Christians. A dubious campaign was begun to deliberately conflate petty hate crimes of the Bajrang Dal type with terrorism, the ultimate purpose being to make the definition of terrorism so broad that the actual Islamic terrorists would never come under the scanner. Justice Nanavati's new report has given a new lease of life to the "secular" parties and their concubines in the media. After all, the Gujarat riots are an adrenaline rush for all liberals.

Civil rights, of course, are the pillars of any democracy. In fact, India faces the wrath of Jihadi forces precisely because Islam is the antithesis of civil rights. The purpose of civil rights legislation is protect the dignity of the individual and not to undercut law enforcement in general. In fact, should the human rights crowd become successful in further restricting the hand of the law in India, we the people will have to pay for it by ultimately having to go through a state of Internal Emergency. Already, India faces its worst internal security situation since independence; if things go worse from this point, law and order will have to be restored by imposing Emergency, at which point all civil rights will be dissolved, thus resulting in a net loss for the cause of personal liberty.

There is no one magic formula that can end terrorism. For one, terrorism is not restricted to India, but operates on a global scale. The Oracle advances the following "tree model" for terrorism:

a) The branches of the terror tree are the Jihadi elements who carry out the actual crimes.

b) The trunk of the terror tree is the structure of Islam itself and the attitude of Islam towards the outside world. Islam, like any other religion, is simply a lens, a certain worldview, which, in this case sees people simply in terms of believers and non believers.

c) The roots of the terror tree plunge deep into the oil wells of Saudi Arabia, from where the radical Wahabis run their campaign against the civilized world.


Therefore, terrorism has to be dealt with at all three levels. A good way to start would be to hand over exemplary punishments to Jihadi elements within our society. This is important not only because this is what they deserve, but also because Jihadi elements often see our democratic institutions as a sign of weakness. The liberal mob in the media is wrong; there is no way to win the hearts of terrorists (potential and active) by offering them more in way of civil rights.

Of course, the Hindu fanatics are wrong as well; there is no way either to outfanaticize the Muslim fanatics. Dealing with the Jihadi elements will require the State Governments to act on the long overdue plans for police reform, besides the Central Government creating a special agency to fight terrorism, if not a set of fast track courts equipped with special powers and specific laws. The Indian response has been, thus far, woefully inadequate, with the Central Government still unable to make up its mind on even a workable definition of terrorism.

Dealing with Part b) of the terrorist problem is even more complex. It will require a change in discourse from all sections of media and Government. Most of the liberal media spends its time on explaining how Muslims are affected by a myriad prejudices in India. The assumption is that, somehow, by giving special favours and loads of media sympathy, one can actually keep Muslims from turning to terrorism. Since all other communities in India and most other parts of the democratic world enjoy roughly the same rights as Muslims, it is difficult to see how appeasing the Muslims could possibly work to dissuade them from turning to fundamentalism. Instead, appeasement is counterproductive; it deepens resentment for Muslims' "protected status" and furthers the cause of separatists.

The right approach is to hold Muslims' feet to the fire. The cause and effect relationship between rampant Islamic terrorism and Islamphobia needs to be explained. Few communities in the world today face so much prejudice as the Muslims, but that is because no other community has had so many members involved in mass murder in the recent past. Virtually every single nation in which Muslims form the majority is a dictatorship that has draconian, openly discriminatory laws against women and homosexuals at the very least and public beheadings, stonings and regular massacres at the worst. Peaceful Muslims should understand that if most of the world needs to be ashamed of its prejudice, Muslims have a lot more to be ashamed of.

All religions are "belief systems" and not all belief systems could possibly be progressive, inclusive and liberal. The idea that "all religions are great" is a fallacy. Any belief system, by definition, defies logic and in doing so, brings great dangers upon us. In fact, the value of religion as a social institution should be questioned.

And finally, as with most afflictions of humanity, we should look to science and logic to redeem us. The horrors of Jihad are financed by the oil billionaires of Saudi Arabia and most of the Middle East. Given the dependence of our institutions on the supply of oil, terrorism is likely to be well financed for many, many decades to come. The Saudis know this and they are exploiting the situation to the fullest. The only solution is to show the savages what wonders can be worked by the ingenuity of civilization. Take, for instance, the example of Brazil, which now runs four fifths of its cars on ethanol extracted from corn. The way out is to follow this example and build a community of like minded nations that can take the world away from both blood and oil.

Wednesday, 24 September 2008

US distributes eye candy; wins several friends!


Okay, that was just a joke. But how come the conservatives have it easy all the hotties, while the lesbian feminists with mustaches flock to liberal ranks?



Note: For sometime now, I have wanted to have a photograph of Gov. Palin on this blog. I hope Americans elect her vice President, if only to spice up the nightly news. The Vice Presidential debates, wherein Sarah Palin goes head to head with foreign policy eagle Joseph Biden, should help in answering the age old question: Beauty or Brains?